Organisations build their leadership development around skills: communication workshops, strategy modules, coaching certifications, presentation training. All useful stuff, but how well any of it lands depends heavily on who's sitting in that room. A leader who already knows their own blind spots and default behaviours will pick up new skills far quicker than one who's never stopped to think about how they actually come across. That's why self-awareness belongs at the front of any L&D plan, and there's a body of research to back it up.
In 2017, McKinsey found that only 11% of executives believe their leadership development programmes achieve and sustain the intended results. One recurring explanation is that programmes teach behaviours without first helping leaders understand how they show up under pressure. So what does it look like when you put self-awareness first, and why does the order make such a difference to everything that follows?
Where Most Development Plans Go Wrong
The typical leadership programme follows a skills-first structure. Participants arrive, they're taught frameworks for giving feedback or making decisions, and they leave with a toolkit they're expected to apply on Monday morning. The trouble is, most of those tools won't stick if the leader hasn't first looked at their own patterns and habits.
Take the leader who doesn't realise they dominate every conversation. A module on active listening won't do much for them. They'll nod along during the session, tick the box, and revert to their default within a week. A 2019 Rutbusters survey of 1,000 UK senior managers found that 34% said there was no training programme for senior executives at their organisation at all, which means the leaders who do get development need it to count from the very first session. Teaching communication theory when the actual gap is self-knowledge will burn through limited resources and limited patience in equal measure.
What Self-Awareness Actually Means in This Context
Self-awareness in leadership development isn't navel-gazing. It's about establishing a factual baseline so the rest of the programme has something real to build on. Tools like 360-degree feedback and psychometric profiling give leaders structured, evidence-based insight into how they're perceived by their teams, their peers and their own managers.
That feedback tends to reveal gaps between intention and impact that can be genuinely surprising. A leader might believe they're decisive and clear, while their direct reports actually experience them as dismissive and rushed. If that disconnect isn't surfaced early, any training in stakeholder management or team engagement will miss the point entirely because it'll be solving a problem that doesn't match the real one. Some providers now build their programmes around that principle. For example, the popular T2 leadership retreat puts 360-degree feedback on day one, so the leaders in the room have seen their own results before a single session on skills begins, and the days that follow get aimed at the gaps the feedback exposed.
Why Sequencing Changes the Outcome
The order matters, and not just because leaders end up with more information about themselves. When they start with self-awareness, they're far more likely to engage with subsequent skill-building modules on a personal level instead of treating them as abstract theory. A feedback exercise that tells you your team finds you unapproachable turns a generic module on coaching conversations into something urgent and very specific to you.
The same principle applies at team level too. Leaders who've done their own self-awareness work tend to create more psychologically safe environments for their teams to do the same, and that has a compounding effect across the organisation over time. Development plans that skip this step will often produce leaders who can describe good leadership in theory but don't recognise the gap between that description and their own daily behaviour in meetings, under deadlines and during difficult conversations.
What This Means for How Organisations Invest in Leaders
The bigger question here is about return on investment. When budgets are tight and only a fraction of senior leaders receive any formal development at all, getting the sequence wrong costs real money. Organisations that lead with skills training often find themselves running the same programmes year after year because the underlying behavioural patterns haven't actually changed.
Self-awareness isn't a soft or indulgent starting point. Think of it as the diagnostic step that tells you which skills genuinely need developing and where the real blockers are. Without it, L&D plans risk turning into a cycle of content delivery that looks productive on paper but doesn't change how leaders perform when things get difficult. For any organisation that's serious about developing its senior leaders, the question isn't whether to include self-awareness in the plan. It's whether they can afford to leave it until later.











